All reports
Beer & Bread reports
#151469: "Harvest action did not give all resources"
notabug: This is not a bug
2
What is this report about?
What happened? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been followed
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not followed by the BGA adaptation?
when harvesting resources, you harvest the resources shown on the card PLUS any previously played harvest cards. I had previously played a harvest card with barley (brown resource) on it but it was not given to me.• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
Yes, on move 38 themeaningofsam tried to harvest. I should have been allowed to pick up one barley (to add to the one I already had) but it was not available to choose when selecting which resources to keep.• Which browser are you using?
Google Chrome v131
Report history
Jan 1st 2025 0:03 • tchobello • This is not a bug:
hello,
you should have a look at the tutorial...
you've harvested Water & Rye and should get any other Water and Rye harvested before, not any previously played resource.
you should have a look at the tutorial...
you've harvested Water & Rye and should get any other Water and Rye harvested before, not any previously played resource.
Jan 31st 2025 17:26 • Mark F • This is not a bug:
I don't have a screenshot, but there were several occurrences where I did not get the orange resource. Once during my harvest phase and once when my opponent was forced to give me a resource. When we looked at the game log, we saw where my opponent tried to give me an orange resource, but it never showed up in my storage areas. In both cases, I did have available space. This only happened with orange.
Jan 31st 2025 17:48 • tchobello • More information is requested by developers to reproduce this bug:
thanks, Mark..
Have you checked first if there were still orange resources in the field ?
Watch back the game replay and then you'll know.
Have you checked first if there were still orange resources in the field ?
Watch back the game replay and then you'll know.
Feb 3rd 2025 19:36 • Jordofolis • More information is requested by developers to reproduce this bug:
Move Id 33
imgur.com/a/bDk8z9Y
(white arrow) Earlier: played a harvest card, got 2 barley (+1 with upgrade) 1 wheat.
(pink arrow, move 33): played a two rye card, got one rye (field empty of rye), expecting also 2 more barley (2 are in field AND i have an upgrade for empty barley fields) and also 1 wheat (wheat is available).
Overall looks like first harvest card did not even trigger when playing the second.
imgur.com/a/bDk8z9Y
(white arrow) Earlier: played a harvest card, got 2 barley (+1 with upgrade) 1 wheat.
(pink arrow, move 33): played a two rye card, got one rye (field empty of rye), expecting also 2 more barley (2 are in field AND i have an upgrade for empty barley fields) and also 1 wheat (wheat is available).
Overall looks like first harvest card did not even trigger when playing the second.
Feb 3rd 2025 21:03 • tchobello • This is not a bug:
Hello Jordofolis...
as written just above:
when playing 2 Rye card, you should get any other Rye harvested before, NOT any previously played resource.
as written just above:
when playing 2 Rye card, you should get any other Rye harvested before, NOT any previously played resource.
Feb 3rd 2025 21:41 • Jordofolis • This is not a bug:
Got it! notabug acknlowedged.
Easy to overlook, but for anyone else wondering here's the verbatim from the rulebook:
"Play the chosen card face up in front of you. If you already have cards there, place this new card slightly offset on top of them, creating a harvest column, in which the harvest section of each card is still visible. Then check which types of resource are shown in the harvest section of the newly played card. Of **these** types, you must now collect as many tokens from the board as are shown in all harvest sections of your harvest column combined."
Easy to overlook, but for anyone else wondering here's the verbatim from the rulebook:
"Play the chosen card face up in front of you. If you already have cards there, place this new card slightly offset on top of them, creating a harvest column, in which the harvest section of each card is still visible. Then check which types of resource are shown in the harvest section of the newly played card. Of **these** types, you must now collect as many tokens from the board as are shown in all harvest sections of your harvest column combined."
Feb 3rd 2025 23:48 • tchobello • This is not a bug:
there are also pictures in the rulebook explaining it...
Mar 7th 2025 5:06 • Elcarp • This is not a bug:
Table #640115631
Move #82
Progression 57%
I harvested a double barley card and only received one barley, even though I had space for both.
Table #640115631
Move #82
Progression 57%
I harvested a double barley card and only received one barley, even though I had space for both.
Mar 7th 2025 8:47 • tchobello • This is not a bug:
Hello,
have you checked if there were enough in the fields ?
have you checked if there were enough in the fields ?
Mar 21st 2025 14:37 • TBeanster • This is not a bug:
Maybe I am just not getting it but I thought that when I harvested a card, assuming there is space in my storage and enough resources available in the field, why am I not receiving the newly harvested resources AND ALSO the previous offset harvested card of resources? Again, I have double-checked and I had space available in my storage and there were available resources to fill that in the field. This has happened multiple times when playing playing this game on even other tables as well.
Mar 21st 2025 14:55 • tchobello • This is not a bug:
Hello TBeanster,
please give me a table number and a move number where it happens...
please give me a table number and a move number where it happens...
Add to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant in order to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appear several times? Every time? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
